What Happens Next Will Scare You

Melissa LaMartina

Rachel Silver

N/A

Rachel D. Wilson

Myra

N/A

Kalima Young

June

N/A

Kathy Carson

Vanessa

N/A

Troy Jennings

Lester

N/A

Johnny Marra

Eugene Wiley

N/A

Mike C. Walls

Mr. Tickles

N/A

John Bennett

Chuck

N/A

Evangeline Ridgaway

Rose Silver

N/A

Caitlin Rife

Clickbait Zombie

N/A

Cash K. Allen

Viral Video Son

N/A

Wes Allen

Viral Video Dad

N/A

Greg Bowen

Sasquatch

N/A

Erin Reid

Monster Vera

N/A

Sadie Roussell

Ginny Wainwright (segment "Ghost Ruins Birthday Party")

N/A

Tracey Allyn

Mrs. Wainwright (segment "Ghost Ruins Birthday Party")

N/A

Daemon McConnaughey

Greg Wainwright (segment "Ghost Ruins Birthday Party") (voice)

N/A

Mark Burchick

Birthday Party Extra #1 (segment "Ghost Ruins Birthday Party")

N/A

Katharine Vary

Boy's Mom (segment "Ghost Ruins Birthday Party")

N/A

Richard Donahue

Birthday Party Extra #2 (segment "Ghost Ruins Birthday Party")

N/A

Flynn Shea

Boy (segment "Ghost Ruins Birthday Party")

N/A

Cecily Donahue Autumn

Birthday Party Extra #3 (segment "Ghost Ruins Birthday Party")

N/A

Jill George

Birthday Party Extra #4 (segment "Ghost Ruins Birthday Party")

N/A

Brooke Korch

Birthday Party Extra #5 (segment "Ghost Ruins Birthday Party")

N/A

Lisa Logan-Roussell

Birthday Party Extra #6 (segment "Ghost Ruins Birthday Party")

N/A

Geoff Loo

Birthday Party Extra #7 (segment "Ghost Ruins Birthday Party")

N/A

Shelley Loo

Birthday Party Extra #8 (segment "Ghost Ruins Birthday Party")

Kendra North

Officer Rebecca Harrington (segment "Police Dash Cam Captures Bigfoot!")

N/A

Scott Burke

Drunk Guy (segment "Police Dash Cam Captures Bigfoot!")

N/A

Mark Roby

Bigfoot (segment "Police Dash Cam Captures Bigfoot!")

N/A

Maddie Howard

Vera (segment "Vera's Very Very Vlog")

N/A

Brittany Hunt

Maddie's Friend (segment "Vera's Very Very Vlog")

N/A

Craig Peter Coletta

Father Demetri Barrett (segment "How To Perform An Exorcism")

N/A

Mike Jancz

Father Blair Dietz (segment "How To Perform An Exorcism")

N/A

Kristina Green

Possessed Woman (segment "How To Perform An Exorcism")

N/A

Nolen Strals

George O'Bannon (segment "Funeral Home Invasion 911 Call")

Leanna Chamish

911 Operator (segment "Funeral Home Invasion 911 Call") (voice)

N/A

Matt Lake

Rodrick Baines (segment "From The Shadows: Meet Scraps")

George Stover

Charles Goyer (segment "From The Shadows: Meet Scraps")

N/A

Brian St. August

Dr. Louis Berger (segment "From The Shadows: Meet Scraps")

N/A

Helenmary Ball

Claire Berger (segment "From The Shadows: Meet Scraps")

N/A

Ian McCleary

Chip Chapman (segment "Lake Zaca Monster")

N/A

Pat Storck

Chip Arnold (segment "Lake Zaca Monster")

Chris LaMartina

Randy (segment "Lake Zaca Monster") (voice)

N/A

Michael C. Stettes

Weirdos' Victim (segment "Weirdos")

N/A

Letitia Getka

Weirdo #1 (segment "Weirdos")

N/A

Justin Getka

Weirdo #2 (segment "Weirdos")

N/A

Chuck Green

Weirdo #3 (segment "Weirdos")

N/A

Emilie Clingerman

Weirdo #4 (segment "Weirdos")

N/A

AJ Hyde

Drew Blood (segment "Blood Trails")